The Look & Sound of Leadership Podcast header

Hosted by Tom Henschel

How to Answer Questions Powerfully
March 2025

253

A leader was given one goal for his coaching: improve how he answered questions. Knowing he struggled with this not only at work, but at home, he asked his coach for tools.

March 2025

253

How to Answer Questions Powerfully

Tom Henschel

Over Answering with a Wall of Words

Devon was completely non-defensive about the feedback.

His boss, Bianca, had been plain with her admiration: she found him level-headed, far-sighted and good with people. She was equally clear about a specific area of development: Devon needed to get better when he answered questions.

When Devon got asked a question, he started spewing words and people tuned him out. Bianca didn’t want people tuning him out.

In our first coaching conversation, he told me, “I don’t always know I’m doing it while I’m actually doing it, but afterwards…” He gave a smile. “My wife has a sister, Cathy. Whenever she calls, my wife just puts the phone on speaker and keeps on doing whatever she was doing, because Cathy’s a talker! When I give one of those answers, my wife tells me, ‘You’re doing a Cathy.’ And usually, I can see that I did.”

I said, “But you don’t know while you’re doing it.”

“I do, sometimes,” he said. “When I’m nervous, like in front of the board. I feel myself throwing out this wall of words, like some sort of shield. I know I’m doing then, but I can’t stop.”

“I’m curious, within that wall of words, do you answer what’s asked?”

“Oh, for sure,” he said earnestly. “Over-answer, probably. But yes, I absolutely answer the question. At least I think I do.”

“And Bianca thinks people don’t hear it.”

“‘Cause I’m doing a Cathy. “

I asked, “Can you give me an example?”

Don’t Assume You Know Why They Asked

Without pause, he said, “I did one just this morning, in the kitchen. My wife asked me what time I’m leaving for the airport on Saturday. One of my nephews is flying in and I’m picking him up. So, she asks, ‘What time are you leaving?’ and I proceed to tell her my entire schedule for the day. I was trying to be helpful. I wanted her to know I could move things around if she wanted. I could help with things. But finally, she said, ‘Dev, just tell me what time you’re leaving for the airport.’ That was when I knew I’d done it again.”

“You were trying to be helpful,” I said.

“Absolutely. I think that’s the case most of the time, if it’s not my nerves. I really believe I’m the only person who knows my situation, so, when people ask a question, I want to be sure they understand the situation so they can understand my answer.”

I nodded and shrugged. “Being helpful.”

“Right!”

“It’s interesting,” I said. “You seem to be aware of two feelings that trigger the behavior: being nervous and wanting to help. I wonder if those feelings could be like early warning signals for you. When you feel them, pay attention and put extra effort into how you’re answering questions.”

He laughed, “Extra effort? What would that look like?”

I said, “When you feel one of those feelings, think to yourself, ‘I’m only going to answer what they asked, because I have no idea WHY they’re asking this question!’”

“Like this morning. I thought maybe my wife wanted some help, so I answered in the most helpful way I could.”

I asked, “By the way, did you find out why she asked?”

“Oh, yeah, she wanted to know if I was going to overlap with some friends of my daughter, who are coming over. I always like seeing these girls, so she was just asking if I’d be there when they came.”

“So, she wasn’t needing any help,” I said.

“Not by a hundred miles.”

I took a breath, then said quietly, “If you want to get better at answering questions, Dev, start there. Don’t assume you know why anyone is asking anything. Ever. Because you don’t. Just answer what’s asked. Don’t be helpful. Don’t be paranoid. Don’t be anything. Just answer what’s asked.”

The Four Kinds of Questions

“That sounds so simple. Is it that simple?” he asked.

“It can be, yes. If you really listen and hear what’s being asked, then answer what you heard, yes, it can be simple.”

“I don’t think listening is my problem,” he said. “I think I hear the question. It’s the answering part I need to get better at.”

“I have a framework and some tools that can help,” I offered.

“Great, yes, please,” he said.

“Okay. So, the framework around the entire idea of answering questions powerfully goes like this. There are only four kinds of questions you’ll ever get asked in English. Only four. Three of them are in the same category, the other one stands alone. So, to answer questions powerfully, you only need to learn two tools, one for each category.”

He nodded. “Three and one, okay. What do the three have in common?”

“This group of three are all closed-ended questions.” I paused. When he didn’t take the ball, I continued. “The three kinds of closed-ended questions are, Yes/No, Forced Choice, and Short Answer. I think a lot of business gets done in closed-ended questions. ‘Can we hit this milestone?’ That’s yes/no. ‘Are we using these numbers or generating another report?’ Forced choice. ‘How many people are we expecting?’ Short answer. All closed-ended.

Answering Closed-Ended Questions: Four Actions

“So in this closed-ended category, there’s a script for how to answer powerfully. It has four steps. First, answer what’s asked. First! If they ask a yes/no question, you give them a yes or a no. No qualifiers. No explanation. Answer what’s asked. Same if they ask a short answer question. Fill in the blank. Period. No explaining.”

“Because I don’t know why they’re asking,” he said.

“Exactly, yes,” I agreed.

“But listen,” he said, “that’s never going to fly at work. Things at work are complex. If I don’t do some explaining and put some context around things, I’m not doing my job.”

I nodded in agreement. “Which is why there are four steps in the script. This was just the first one. Answer what’s asked. That’s first. You lead with that.

“The second step with closed-ended questions is ‘match length.’ When you get asked a closed-ended question, however long they take to ask the question is about how long you get to answer. Match length. Because that’s about how long they’ll listen.”

He laughed. “That’s me for sure, when I’m the one asking the questions. I want to know what I want to know, and I want to know it now.” He slapped his hand impatiently.

I nodded. “Matching length keeps people’s attention. That was number two. Step number three. ‘Check for understanding.’ Ask the person, ‘Did I answer your question?’ If they say you did, you get to go to number four, which is ‘Fill in all the context.’ This is when you add some detail to your short answer.”

“Oh,” he said, “when they say, yes, I answered their question, it’s like they’re giving me permission to add my stuff. Like they’ve cleared their plate and they’re ready for more.”

I nodded. “They’re ready to listen, yes.”

“And the reverse is true, too, right? If they didn’t answer their question, they’re not ready to listen. That’s how I am as a listener. Oh, wow. I’ve got a lot to learn. And that’s just the three closed-ended questions. Does that mean the stand-alone one is open-ended questions?” he asked.

Answering Open-Ended Questions: Three Actions

“Exactly, the fourth question is anything that’s not yes/no, forced choice or short answer. ‘Why’ questions. ‘How’ questions. Questions that invite explanations.”

He smiled, saying, “That’s sounding like something I’m trying to avoid.”

“No, I don’t want you to be scared of open-ended questions. There’s a script for open-ended questions that is designed exactly to address that concern. It stops you from overtalking and getting off track. There are only three parts. The first part makes you take a step back. Instead of just jumping in and starting to talk, this part says, ‘Begin with a number.’

“So, someone asks you, ‘Why did you choose those deadlines?’ Open-ended, right? Asks for an explanation. You start by stepping back. Assess it. How many ideas are in your answer? You can do it in a second if you’re ready. You say, ‘There were three reasons we picked those dates’ Or, ‘There’s one reason that drove that decision.’ You start your answer with a number.

“Then, the second part: you label your first item. Then, the third part, ‘Talk about that item, but be brief. Encapsulate.’ You’re being asked for an explanation in summary form. ‘Be brief. Encapsulate.’ Then you go back and label your second item and are brief about that. Then, you cycle through the second and third pieces until you’re done.

“I’m going to make something up so you can hear it,” I said. “They ask, ‘Why those deadlines,’ and I say, ‘There were three reasons for those deadlines. The first was budget. We’re going to need help hitting the deadlines, but the budget is there. The second, Anita’s team.  Those deadlines are best for them, so we’re glad to do it. And last is people. We think we can do it without killing people.’ Time out. Did you hear it? I gave each reason a label – budget, Anita’s team, people – then was super brief explaining it. When you get asked an open-ended question, those three steps will help you from pulling a Cathy.”

Devon felt self-conscious and awkward at first. But then he began to feel himself getting better. Even his wife noticed. That’s when he knew for sure he was moving towards The Look & Sound of Leadership. 

Core Concepts:
  • Answering questions powerfully is a leadership skill.
  • Don’t assume you know why people ask what they ask. You don’t.
  • Distinguish open- from closed-ended questions.
  • Scripts for each type are available here.

Related Library Categories:

Free Essential Tool:

 width=
Answer Questions Powerfully

Recent Episodes

Trending Episodes

Scroll to Top